Criminal Code, section 236
Manslaughter
What the law says
- Maximum
- Life imprisonment
- Mandatory minimum
- No mandatory minimum
- Kind of offence
- Violent, causing death
No minimum unless a firearm is used: MMP of 4 years when a firearm is used (s.236(a)); see "Manslaughter with a firearm". S.C. 2026, c. 19 added s.236(2): court must consider life if coercive control, exploitation, sexual or hate-motivated.
63 cases with this offence
- June 9, 2023Four years (1,461 days) less 200 days credit for time served; 10-year weapons prohibition
- April 11, 2023R. v. Sor, 2023 BCSC 642
- Below the Crown's ask
30 months imprisonment less 90 days credit (net 27 months); DNA, s. 109 and forfeiture orders, non-communication order - April 6, 2023R. v. Harry, 2023 BCSC 999
- Below the Crown's ask
Five years' imprisonment less 11 months agreed credit (four years and one month remaining); DNA order and s. 109 prohibition - January 5, 2023R. v. Rhyno, 2023 NSSC 9
- Below the Crown's ask
8 years in prison, less 40 months (1,199 days) credit for pre-sentence custody - November 30, 20226 years less 1,287 days' credit (2 years, 7 months and 18 days remaining); DNA, s. 109 10-year and lifetime prohibitions
- October 25, 2022R. v. Simpson, 2022 NSSC 301
- Below the Crown's ask
30 months in a federal penitentiary; DNA order, 10-year s. 109 prohibition, forfeiture - August 24, 20227 years imprisonment, less 1,364 days enhanced remand credit and 100 days COVID credit (1,091 days going forward)
- July 6, 202218 years' imprisonment (15 years manslaughter, 3 years consecutive abandonment), less 1,374 days' remand credit
- March 11, 2022R. v. Maulen, 2022 BCSC 468
- Below the Crown's ask
20 months and 6 days in prison, less 66 days credit (18 months net); no probation - September 17, 2021R. v. S.N.H., 2021 BCSC 2068
- Below the Crown's ask
- On release at the time
Seven and a half years' imprisonment (90 months), less 29 months' credit for pre-sentence custody (61 months remaining) - September 15, 2021Eight years' incarceration, less 792 days' credit for pre-sentence custody and a further six months for stringent bail (net five years and four months)
- September 7, 2021R. v. T.A.L., 2021 BCSC 1910
- On release at the time
8 years for manslaughter plus 3.5 years consecutive for indignity to a body (11.5 years), less 3 years and 6 days credit - June 25, 2021R. v. Dey, 2021 BCSC 1518
- Below the Crown's ask
6 years less 4 years' credit for pre-sentence custody: 2 years in a federal penitentiary, then 3 years probation
Judges who sentenced this offence
- The Honourable Justice Martha M. Devlin
- The Honourable Justice Patrick J. Duncan
- The Honourable Justice E. David Crossin
- The Honourable Justice Kathleen M. Ker
- The Honourable Justice Michael Tammen
- The Honourable Justice S. Dev Dley
- The Honourable Justice Warren B. Milman
- The Honourable Justice Alison J. Beames
- The Honourable Justice Andrew P. A. Mayer
- The Honourable Justice Catherine Murray
- The Honourable Justice Christa M. Brothers
- The Honourable Justice Eric V. Gottardi
- The Honourable Justice Joshua M. Arnold
- The Honourable Justice Ronald S. Tindale
- The Honourable Justice Sheri A. Donegan
- The Honourable Justice Andrew Majawa
- The Honourable Justice Brenda Brown
- The Honourable Justice David M. Layton
- The Honourable Justice Douglas W. Thompson
- The Honourable Justice Edlyn Laurie
- The Honourable Justice Frits E. Verhoeven
- The Honourable Justice Gary P. Weatherill
- The Honourable Justice George Macintosh
- The Honourable Justice Heather J. Holmes
- The Honourable Justice James L. Chipman
- The Honourable Justice James W. Williams
- The Honourable Justice Jamie S. Campbell
- The Honourable Justice Jeffrey R. Hunt
- The Honourable Justice John A. Keith
- The Honourable Justice John P. Bodurtha