The Honourable Justice

Martha M. Devlin

Supreme Court of British Columbia

Sitting.

Last updated

13 cases tracked, 9 flagged.

Below the Crown's ask
11
No jail for a violent offence
1
Increased on appeal
0
Offender offended again
0

Counts and the score cover the published decisions Sentence Watch has tracked, not every case this judge decided. How cases are chosen.

Leniency score

Rank 8 of 61 scored judges in Canada, 5 of 42 at the Supreme Court of British Columbia. Sentences averaged 36% below the Crown’s ask across 13 comparable cases. The average across judges is 23.

Tracked cases by decision date, 2021 to 2026.
  1. R. v. Johnson-Audain, March 21, 2025
  2. R. v. P.P.A., February 6, 2025, flagged
  3. R. v. H.S., October 9, 2024, flagged
  4. R. v. O.R., July 16, 2024, flagged
  5. R. v. M.S.H., February 29, 2024, flagged
  6. R. v. J.S.H., September 7, 2023, flagged
  7. R. v. J.S.B., September 7, 2023
  8. R. v. J.R.J.B., July 18, 2023, flagged
  9. R. v. Cashman, November 17, 2022
  10. R. v. Coban, October 14, 2022
  11. R. v. Harmes, April 27, 2022, flagged
  12. R. v. Kim, March 29, 2022, flagged
  13. R. v. B.A.V., September 7, 2021, flagged
  • Violent
  • Sexual
  • Other
  • Drugs
  • Firearms
  • Below the Crown's ask
  • Not flagged

Flagged cases

  1. February 6, 2025
    R. v. P.P.A., 2025 BCSC 159Sexual interference; Making child sexual abuse material, New Westminster
    • Below the Crown's ask
    4 years 6 months in custody (3.5 years and 1 year consecutive), less 1,272 days credit, then 2 years probation
  2. October 9, 2024
    R. v. H.S., 2024 BCSC 1869Manslaughter; Aggravated assault, Surrey
    • Below the Crown's ask
    10 years global (2 years concurrent on each aggravated assault), less 2,177 days pre-trial credit
  3. July 16, 2024
    R. v. O.R., 2024 BCSC 1288Manslaughter; Indignity to human remains, Langley
    • Below the Crown's ask
    16 years in custody (11 years manslaughter, 5 years consecutive indignity to remains) less 1,413 days' credit
  4. February 29, 2024
    R. v. M.S.H., 2024 BCSC 366Manslaughter, Surrey
    • Below the Crown's ask
    6 years' imprisonment (2,190 days), less 248 days' credit for pre-trial custody
  5. September 7, 2023
    R. v. J.S.H., 2023 BCSC 1564Manslaughter, Surrey
    • Below the Crown's ask
    3 years imprisonment less 105 days credit for pre-sentence custody
  6. July 18, 2023
    R. v. J.R.J.B., 2023 BCSC 1202Manslaughter, Surrey
    • Below the Crown's ask
    8 years' imprisonment, less 1,787 days' credit for pre-sentence custody
  7. April 27, 2022
    R. v. Harmes, 2022 BCSC 663Possession of a loaded prohibited or restricted firearm; Possession of a Schedule I or II substance for the purpose of trafficking; Possession of a weapon contrary to a prohibition order, Mission
    • Below the Crown's ask
    14 years global (12 years on drug/firearm indictment plus 2 years consecutive for breaching firearms prohibitions), less 977 days credit (net 4,133 days)
  8. March 29, 2022
    R. v. Kim, 2022 BCSC 518Possession of a loaded prohibited or restricted firearm; Possession of a Schedule I or II substance for the purpose of trafficking; Trafficking or possession for trafficking (Schedule IV substance), Richmond
    • Below the Crown's ask
    10 years global custody (all counts concurrent)
  9. September 7, 2021
    R. v. B.A.V., 2021 BCSC 1773Sexual interference, Vernon
    • Below the Crown's ask
    • No jail for a violent offence
    23 months conditional (11 months and 12 months consecutive), then 3 years probation

Other tracked cases

  1. March 21, 2025
    R. v. Johnson-Audain, 2025 BCSC 539Conspiracy to commit murder, Surrey
    Six years' imprisonment, less 1,047 days' credit for pre-sentence custody
  2. September 7, 2023
    R. v. J.S.B., 2023 BCSC 1514Obstructing justice, Surrey
    18 months conditional sentence
  3. November 17, 2022
    R. v. Cashman, 2022 BCSC 1836Possession of a Schedule I or II substance for the purpose of trafficking, Mission
    6 years global (6 years on the fentanyl count, other counts concurrent), less 45 days credit for pre-sentence custody
  4. October 14, 2022
    R. v. Coban, 2022 BCSC 1810Distributing child sexual abuse material; Luring a child; Criminal harassment; Extortion, New Westminster
    13 years global (8 years extortion, 1 year consecutive for possession of child pornography for distribution, 4 years consecutive for luring, 6 years concurrent for criminal harassment), consecutive to his Dutch sentence

Offences sentenced

Professional background

No sourced background yet.

publicly
Sentence Watch is part of Publicly: sites built from government and court records, with every fact linked to its source. Publicly is not affiliated with any government. Visits are counted with Google Analytics, which sets cookies.