Judges by leniency score

42 judges scored in British Columbia

1. 3
   The Honourable Justice Lindsay M. LysterSupreme Court of British Columbia
   38

   45% below the Crown's ask on average. 7 of 11 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

2. 4
   The Honourable Justice Catherine MurraySupreme Court of British Columbia
   34

   38% below the Crown's ask on average. 3 of 7 cases below the ask, 2 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

3. 5
   The Honourable Justice Marguerite H. ChurchSupreme Court of British Columbia
   34

   41% below the Crown's ask on average. 6 of 7 cases below the ask. See the cases

4. 7
   The Honourable Justice John Gibb-CarsleySupreme Court of British Columbia
   34

   42% below the Crown's ask on average. 4 of 5 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

5. 8
   The Honourable Justice Martha M. DevlinSupreme Court of British Columbia
   33

   36% below the Crown's ask on average. 11 of 13 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

6. 10
   The Honourable Justice Gareth MorleySupreme Court of British Columbia
   33

   43% below the Crown's ask on average. 3 of 5 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

7. 11
   The Honourable Justice Palbinder Kaur ShergillSupreme Court of British Columbia
   32

   36% below the Crown's ask on average. 4 of 5 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

8. 12
   The Honourable Justice E. David CrossinSupreme Court of British Columbia
   31

   34% below the Crown's ask on average. 5 of 6 cases below the ask. See the cases

9. 14
   The Honourable Justice Michael J. BrundrettSupreme Court of British Columbia
   28

   30% below the Crown's ask on average. 3 of 6 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

10. 15
    The Honourable Justice Robin A. M. BairdSupreme Court of British Columbia
    27

    29% below the Crown's ask on average. 7 of 14 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

11. 18
    The Honourable Justice Geoffrey B. GomerySupreme Court of British Columbia
    27

    29% below the Crown's ask on average. 3 of 5 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

12. 21
    The Honourable Justice Alan M. RossSupreme Court of British Columbia
    24

    22% below the Crown's ask on average. 7 of 13 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

13. 23
    The Honourable Justice Jennifer M.I. DuncanSupreme Court of British Columbia
    23

    22% below the Crown's ask on average. 3 of 6 cases below the ask. See the cases

14. 24
    The Honourable Justice Briana HardwickSupreme Court of British Columbia
    22

    19% below the Crown's ask on average. 8 of 12 cases below the ask. See the cases

15. 25
    The Honourable Justice Gary P. WeatherillSupreme Court of British Columbia
    22

    22% below the Crown's ask on average. 6 of 12 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

16. 27
    The Honourable Justice Sheri A. DoneganSupreme Court of British Columbia
    22

    22% below the Crown's ask on average. 4 of 9 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

17. 28
    The Honourable Justice Elizabeth McDonaldSupreme Court of British Columbia
    22

    21% below the Crown's ask on average. 4 of 7 cases below the ask. See the cases

18. 31
    The Honourable Justice Sharon MatthewsSupreme Court of British Columbia
    20

    16% below the Crown's ask on average. 4 of 8 cases below the ask. See the cases

19. 32
    The Honourable Justice W. Paul RileySupreme Court of British Columbia
    20

    17% below the Crown's ask on average. 3 of 8 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

20. 33
    The Honourable Justice Andrew MajawaSupreme Court of British Columbia
    20

    16% below the Crown's ask on average. 2 of 5 cases below the ask. See the cases

21. 34
    The Honourable Justice Bradford F. SmithSupreme Court of British Columbia
    20

    16% below the Crown's ask on average. 3 of 5 cases below the ask. See the cases

22. 35
    The Honourable Justice Janet WinteringhamSupreme Court of British Columbia
    20

    14% below the Crown's ask on average. 4 of 5 cases below the ask. See the cases

23. 37
    The Honourable Justice Miriam A. MaisonvilleSupreme Court of British Columbia
    20

    15% below the Crown's ask on average. 2 of 5 cases below the ask. See the cases

24. 38
    The Honourable Justice Wendy A. BakerSupreme Court of British Columbia
    20

    16% below the Crown's ask on average. 2 of 6 cases below the ask. See the cases

25. 39
    The Honourable Justice Jan BrongersSupreme Court of British Columbia
    19

    15% below the Crown's ask on average. 4 of 7 cases below the ask. See the cases

26. 40
    The Honourable Justice S. Dev DleySupreme Court of British Columbia
    19

    12% below the Crown's ask on average. 4 of 6 cases below the ask. See the cases

27. 41
    The Honourable Justice D. Allan BettonSupreme Court of British Columbia
    19

    15% below the Crown's ask on average. 2 of 6 cases below the ask. See the cases

28. 43
    The Honourable Justice Steven WilsonSupreme Court of British Columbia
    18

    14% below the Crown's ask on average. 7 of 15 cases below the ask. See the cases

29. 44
    The Honourable Justice Ardith WalkemSupreme Court of British Columbia
    18

    14% below the Crown's ask on average. 3 of 6 cases below the ask. See the cases

30. 45
    The Honourable Justice Kathleen M. KerSupreme Court of British Columbia
    17

    14% below the Crown's ask on average. 7 of 14 cases below the ask. See the cases

31. 47
    The Honourable Justice Murray B. BlokSupreme Court of British Columbia
    16

    11% below the Crown's ask on average. 6 of 10 cases below the ask. See the cases

32. 48
    The Honourable Justice Andrew P. A. MayerSupreme Court of British Columbia
    16

    7% below the Crown's ask on average. 3 of 8 cases below the ask. See the cases

33. 49
    The Honourable Justice Anthony SaundersSupreme Court of British Columbia
    16

    7% below the Crown's ask on average. 2 of 7 cases below the ask. See the cases

34. 50
    The Honourable Justice Shelley C. FitzpatrickSupreme Court of British Columbia
    16

    5% below the Crown's ask on average. 2 of 7 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

35. 51
    The Honourable Justice Warren B. MilmanSupreme Court of British Columbia
    15

    10% below the Crown's ask on average. 6 of 10 cases below the ask. See the cases

36. 52
    The Honourable Justice Ronald S. TindaleSupreme Court of British Columbia
    15

    4% below the Crown's ask on average. 2 of 6 cases below the ask. See the cases

37. 53
    The Honourable Justice Kenneth W. BallSupreme Court of British Columbia
    15

    7% below the Crown's ask on average. 1 of 5 cases below the ask. See the cases

38. 54
    The Honourable Justice Simon R. CovalSupreme Court of British Columbia
    15

    7% below the Crown's ask on average. 3 of 5 cases below the ask. See the cases

39. 57
    The Honourable Justice Baljinder Kaur GirnSupreme Court of British Columbia
    14

    6% below the Crown's ask on average. 2 of 7 cases below the ask. See the cases

40. 58
    The Honourable Justice Terence A. SchultesSupreme Court of British Columbia
    14

    4% below the Crown's ask on average. 1 of 6 cases below the ask, 1 with no jail for a violent offence. See the cases

41. 60
    The Honourable Justice Heather J. HolmesSupreme Court of British Columbia
    12

    7% below the Crown's ask on average. 7 of 16 cases below the ask. See the cases

42. 61
    The Honourable Justice Carla L. ForthSupreme Court of British Columbia
    12

    6% below the Crown's ask on average. 3 of 8 cases below the ask. See the cases

Not enough comparable cases yet

• The Honourable Justice Barbara J. Norell4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Brenda Brown4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice David A. Crerar4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Eric V. Gottardi4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice F. Matthew Kirchner4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Geoffrey R. J. Gaul4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Heather MacNaughton4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Ian Caldwell4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Jasmin Z. Ahmad4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Jasvinder S. Basran4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Lindsay R. LeBlanc4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Margot L. Fleming4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Michael Tammen4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Richard Hewson4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Sandra M. Sukstorf4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Sandra Wilkinson4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Ward K. Branch4 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Andrea L. Ormiston3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Bruce Elwood3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Catherine A. Wedge3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Christopher J. Giaschi3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Christopher W. Greenwood3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Douglas W. Thompson3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Francesca V. Marzari3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Frits E. Verhoeven3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice J. Miriam Gropper3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Jacqueline D. Hughes3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Joseph M. Doyle3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice K. Michael Stephens3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Laura B. Gerow3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Lisa A. Warren3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Lorianna Bennett3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Nathan H. Smith3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Neena Sharma3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Robert W. Jenkins3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Veronica Jackson3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Y. Liliane Bantourakis3 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Alison J. Beames2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Amy D. Francis2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Anita Chan2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice David M. Layton2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Diane C. MacDonald2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice George Macintosh2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice James W. Williams2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Jeanne E. Watchuk2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice John J. Steeves2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice John Walker2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Judith E. Hoffman2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Julianne K. Lamb2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Karrie A. Wolfe2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Maria Morellato2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Peter H. Edelmann2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Ronald A. Skolrood2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Tina L. Dion2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Trevor C. Armstrong2 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Barbara M. Young1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice David K. Jones1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Edlyn Laurie1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Elin Sigurdson1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Emily M. Burke1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Gordon S. Funt1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice H. William Veenstra1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Jennifer Lynn Whately1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Karen Horsman1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Kevin D. Loo1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Lisa J. Hamilton1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Michael G. Thomas1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Nitya Iyer1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Richard Fowler1 of 5 comparable
• The Honourable Justice Scott Morishita1 of 5 comparable